Introduction
In his most recent Saturday Night Live appearance, multi-talented singer, songwriter, actor, comedian and packaging expert Justin Timberlake had only one truly "disappointing" sketch in a slew of old and new favorites that (somehow) surpassed the incredibly high expectations of the audience and made it's way as one of the shows highest rated episodes of the season.
Yet, in "The Tales Of Sober Caligula", based on the allegedly notorious Roman Emperor who was blamed for everything from wild drunk orgies, to incest, to mass murder, to naming his horse a senator, to you name it which eventually led to his assassination by his own guards in 41 AD.
The humor of the sketch comes from a new and reformed leader bent on changing his debaucherous ways, and his loyal subjects who expected something much more scandalous than game night.
It's no wonder why the skit doesn't work; in addition to it's shaky premise (it might play better if the stakes were higher, or hell, if people knew who Caligula was), and the fact that it runs a bit long, the sketch falls flat before even getting a chance to go anywhere. Ultimately, one can almost sense that the humor is hiding somewhere just under the surface, but what made it to air was merely a brief sparkle in Justin's eye.
It's a below average sketch (for any number of reasons that may or may not even be under anyone's control), and, hindsight should've been replaced, if at all possible.
What makes this so significant is that the commonly known rules of the show dictate that the star gets final say on what goes to air or not, which is the underlying problem of the Caligula sketch, and also of the superb and recently released "The 20/20 Experience", the latest musical contribution the jack-of-all-trades Justin Timberlake has bequeathed upon the world, and it suffers in much the same way.
Pictured: Justin in the studio
The production throughout the ten (or twelve) tracks is all high-quality, and more often than not, well-crafted, thanks to his continued collaboration with Timbaland which is quite apparent throughout the album, showing a distinction from his Missy Elliott past, while still remaining true to the style that caught his BFF Justin's eye for FutureSex/LoveSound. The problem comes into play when he attempts to further his role, specifically by rapping or adlibbing or sampling his voice all annoyingly, it's those songs that suffer most (see Timbaland's verse in "Dress On" for a quick example).
On one hand, Timbaland's production style makes the album, fusing perfectly with Justin's lyrical style and direction. On the other hand, anything that Timbaland touches that goes past purely producing, ends up ruining, like a King Midas but with monosyllabic grunts and jagged, mis-rhymed flows coming out of his hands instead of gold.
Justin's is ultimately at fault here of course, for as much of the credit of the fantastic album goes to him, so does the blame. Not only does he provide some of the most cringe-worthy lyrics ever, his most egregious mistake for letting these ill-advised decisions make it all the way to the album (or to air, as it were).
So for good or bad, let's take a nice long look and listen to Justin Timberlake's "The 20/20 Experience" in this month's Top Nine.